So I had an overwhelming number of people tell me that my color choices were "genius" and "the only colors people should use," and I'm not about to argue with responses like that, right? Unfortunately, I can't find those comments to show you, but just trust me, people loved my work.
The next step, then, is to create an icon for the logo. I have a few rules that I like for logos, which fly right into the face of most logo designs you see nowadays. I prefer logos that retain their quality when enlarged, shrunk, or placed on all types of media (business cards, stationary, clothing, etc). Complicated logos, which are usually pretty cool looking, suffer in form when the functional needs multiply. We want to keep that balance, here.
With those points in mind, I opened up my Photoshop app and started to hack on the following icon, which I am now calling the "StarDrop."
The background:
The raindrop:
The star:

The colors:
So, two shapes and three colors and that's about all it takes to design the StarDrop. Unremarkable in its look compared to logos that aim to shock and awe, but I think this logo can carry the brand for a while and it won't get stale with age...until we get a budget the size of the Wyoming GDP and decide that a two-month-long design process with a graphic design shop is worth our while (frankly, I hope it never is).
So, now that the shapes and frame has been chosen, we just have to decide the arrangement of the colors. Below are the options:

So, I prefer the blue-filled or red-filled StarDrops, but I wanted to get a few opinions on whether folks like the other three. Let me know if you have an opinion.
In the next installment, I'll add text and choose a font for the logo.